It's over: In feisty second night of Democratic debates, Joe Biden was battered, Kamala Harris strong

CLOSE

Who won a Democratic discuss stays to be seen, yet here are some of a best moments from a initial 10 contenders to take a stage.
USA TODAY

Ten Democratic presidential candidates spent dual hours Thursday articulate process and ring in the second spin of a two-part debate. The eventuality kicked off a array of showdowns among a Democratic contenders to take on President Donald Trump.

Feisty discuss ends … see we in July 

11 p.m. Part 2 of a initial Democratic debate ended during 11 p.m.

The exchanges were feistier than on Wednesday, and during times some-more poignant.

Joe Biden, as predicted, became a aim from his center-stage roost for a other possibilities who were anticipating to mangle his lead in polling. A defining impulse of a discuss came in an sell between Biden and Kamala Harris, who slammed a former clamp boss for what she described as “hurtful” past comments on race.

In another jaw-dropping moment, Pete Buttigieg was pulpy on a discuss surrounding a sharpened of a black masculine by a white military officer in South Bend, Indiana, where he is mayor.

Asked given his military force has spin reduction different underneath his watch, Buttigieg offering a note of piety singular on a inhabitant discuss stage.

“Because we couldn’t get it done,” Buttigieg said. “My village is in agonise right now.”

The twin debates this week have remarkable a branch indicate in a early proviso of a 2020 election, capturing a courtesy of many Americans who were not formerly following a Democratic competition closely. More than 15 million people watched a discuss on a initial night. 

Democratic debates: Four hours. 20 candidates. And a race, defined.

Don’t get divorced given of Trump.The tough work of settling America’s domestic differences

To validate for a subsequent debate, possibilities contingency check during 1 percent in during slightest 3 surveys between Jan 1 and dual weeks before a discuss (or accommodate other requirements). That means that many possibilities who competent this week have already competent for a subsequent debate. 

Detroit will horde that subsequent debate, on Jul 30-31 – another two-night affair.

Between now and then, a new spin of polling will strike a margin in an bid to sign who achieved best. Critical second-quarter fundraising reports will be finished open mid-July, another denote of that possibilities are holding off and that are being left behind.

Closing lines

10:57 p.m.  Here are a candidates’ shutting lines:

Kamala Harris: The former prosecutor said Democrats need a hopeful who can “prosecute” a box opposite 4 some-more years of Donald Trump. “I will do that,” she said, adding she will broach a “3 a.m. agenda” to bargain with issues that keep Americans watchful during night, such as health caring and profitable their bills.

Marianne Williamson: She said Donald Trump has gotten into a American essence by harnessing fear for domestic purposes. She pronounced she would overcome that fear and kick Trump by embracing love. “Love will win,” she said.

John Hickenlooper: “You don’t need vast supervision to do vast things…If we spin toward socialism we run a risk of assisting to reelect a misfortune boss in American history.”

Andrew Yang: “I am explanation that a democracy still works,” he said. “I can build a many broader bloc to kick Donald Trump.”

Eric Swalwell: “I have led a bid to elect a subsequent era of members of Congress and we have a impulse to seize…This era final confidant solutions, that’s given I’m regulating for president.”

Michael Bennet: “The ability for one era to do softened than a subsequent is now exceedingly during risk in a United States, generally among children vital in misery like a ones we used to work for in a Denver Public Schools. That’s given I’m regulating for president.”

Pete Buttigieg: “I’m regulating given a decisions we make in a subsequent 3 or 4 years are going to confirm how a subsequent 30 or 40 go. And when we get to a stream age of a stream boss in a year 2055, we wish to be means to demeanour behind on these years and contend my era delivered meridian solutions, secular equality, and an finish to unconstrained war.”

Joe Biden: “I’m regulating to lead this republic given we consider it’s critical we revive a essence of this nation. This boss has ripped it out.”

Kirsten Gillibrand: “[Women’s] rights are underneath conflict like never before by Donald Trump and a Republicans who wish to dissolution Roe v. Wade…As president, we will take on a fights no one else will.”

Bernie Sanders: He pronounced a republic contingency “have a guts” to take on Wall Street, a word industry, a curative industry, a military-industrial complex and a hoary fuel industry.

Sanders snaps during Maddow over guns

10:55 p.m. During a contention on addressing gun violence, Bernie Sanders was confronted with a critique he finished in 2013 that a decisions are best finished by states.

“That’s a mischaracterization,” Sanders said.

“That’s a quote,” responded judge Rachel Maddow.

– Maureen Groppe 

Break adult with Russia, make adult with NATO

10:51 p.m. Here’s what all a possibilities pronounced when asked that republic they would call initial to reset a U.S. attribute (although not all followed instructions):

Marianne Williamson: European leaders.

John Hickenlooper: China.

Andrew Yang: China.

Pete Buttigieg: Would indication American values during home.

Joe Biden: NATO.

Bernie Sanders: United Nations.

Kamala Harris: NATO.

Kristen Gillibrand: Iran.

Michael Bennet: Latin America.

Eric Swalwell: Breaking adult with Russia and creation adult with NATO.

– Maureen Groppe  

What would we do on Day 1?

10:38 p.m. In a doubt that mostly comes adult on a discuss route – yet that many of a possibilities seemed confused for – a moderators asked what is a initial thing any would do in bureau if they are inaugurated president. Here were a answers:

Eric Swalwell: Ending gun violence.

Michael Bennet: Addressing meridian change.

Kirsten Gillibrand: Approving  a family check of rights.

Kamala Harris: A middle-class taxation cut.

Bernie Sanders: Challenged a grounds of a question, arguing there are too many issues to collect one. Moderators remarkable they were seeking for a initial object Sanders would tackle.

Joe Biden: The former clamp boss pronounced his initial emanate would be to better Donald Trump (though many on amicable media forked out that, if he was inaugurated boss he would have already degraded Trump by definition).

Pete Buttigieg: Fix U.S. democracy “before it’s too late.”

Andrew Yang: $1,000 “freedom dividend.”

John Hickenlooper: Climate change

Marianne Williamson: Said her initial call would be to a primary minster of New Zealand to safeguard a U.S. is a best place for a child to grow up.

– John Fritze and Michael Collins

Torch strain reprise 

10:28 p.m. After Joe Biden and Bernie Sanders gave their answers to what they would do to residence meridian change, Eric Swalwell saw another eventuality to disagree for a new era of leaders.

“Here’s a solution. Pass a torch,” Swalwell said. “Pass a flame to a era that’s going to feel a effects of meridian change.”

– Maureen Groppe 

Targeting a VP: Biden on a defensive as Democratic rivals take aim

‘My village is in anguish’

10:24 p.m. Coming off a tough week of traffic with a sharpened of a black masculine by a white military officer in his community, South Bend, Indiana, Mayor Pete Buttigieg was asked given his military force has spin reduction different underneath his watch.

“Because we couldn’t get it done,” Buttigieg said. “My village is in agonise right now.”

His response to a sharpened has been faulted by African Americans in South Bend, as good as a military department.

And David Axelrod, who served as Barack Obama’s arch strategist, pronounced a intelligent claimant missed a possibility to emotionally bond with a village during a contentious town gymnasium Sunday.

Perhaps with that critique in mind, Buttigieg pronounced that when he looks in a eyes of Eric Logan’s mother, “I have to face a fact that zero that we contend will pierce him back.”

But both John Hickenlooper and Eric Swalwell jumped in to impugn his leadership, with a latter revelation Buttigieg he should glow a military chief.

– Maureen Groppe

Harris to Biden: Your comments were ‘hurtful’

10:14 p.m. In one of a defining moments of a debate, Kamala Harris challenged Joe Biden over his remarks final week about operative with segregationist senators James Eastland and Herman Talmadge.

Biden, appearing during a fund-raiser, was deliberating a need for politeness in Congress, and he mentioned a dual Southerners as examples of senators he has worked with in a past.

“We got things done,” he said.

The remarks overwhelmed off a anger in some circles.

Turning to Biden, Harris pronounced she doesn’t consider he’s racist, yet she pronounced it’s “hurtful” to hear him pronounce about anticipating common belligerent with dual senators who built their repute and career on segregation.

Harris cited Biden’s quarrel opposite propagandize busing and told a story of a immature California lady who was partial of a second category to confederate her school. “That small lady is me,” she said.

Biden watched mill faced as Harris pounded him. When he got his possibility to speak, he dismissed behind during Harris, job her critique a “mischaracterization.”

Biden also seemed to impugn Harris for being a prosecutor.

“I was a open defender,” Biden told Harris. “I didn’t spin a prosecutor.”

Biden argued he didn’t conflict busing yet rather opposite sovereign doing of that policy. “I did not conflict busing in America,” Biden said. “I opposite busing by a Department of Education.”

Biden afterwards pronounced his time was up.

– Michael Collins and John Fritze

Trump trade policies slammed 

10:06 p.m. President Trump’s trade policies are underneath conflict from 3 candidates.

John Hickenlooper pronounced a administration is right to pull behind opposite China’s astray trade policies yet has left about it a wrong way.

Andrew Yang pronounced a tariffs that Trump has slapped on Chinese products are punishing businesses and workers.

Pete Buttigieg pronounced a U.S. needs to deposit in programs to urge a competitiveness of American businesses.

“We have to denote that we indeed caring about authorized values during home,” Buttigieg said.

– Michael Collins

Where is a president? Trump arrives during G20 angry about allies Germany, India and his host, Japan

Merkel wordless as Trump mocks Dems

10:04 p.m. President Donald Trump mocked a Democrats before a G-20 assembly with Angela Merkel, revelation a German chancellor he would rather be “spending time with we than watching.”

Trump is roving in Japan for a G-20, yet is clearly gripping an eye on a Democratic debate. The boss is weighing in on 2020 politics notwithstanding a longstanding tradition that U.S. officials will leave politics “at a water’s edge” when they are roving abroad. 

Citing final night’s Democratic debate, Trump told Merkel that “it wasn’t really exciting, we can tell we that.”

Merkel showed no greeting whatsoever to a comments.

– David Jackson

Biden’s finger

9:57 p.m. Reopening an emanate that featured heavily on Wednesday, moderators asked a possibilities to lift their hands if they believe entering a republic illegally should be a rapist rather than a polite offense. Most of a possibilities put adult a hand.

Joe Biden put adult a finger.

“I don’t know if we lifted your palm or were usually seeking to speak,” judge Mario Díaz-Balart said.

Biden went on to cite all of a changes he would make – promulgation additional assist to Central America, finale a use of family separations – yet never simplified his position on either entering a republic illegally should be a polite contra a rapist issue.

Michael Bennet did not lift his hand.

The emanate came adult Wednesday when Julián Castro called on a other possibilities to support repealing a sustenance of a law that creates bootleg entrance a crime.

– John Fritze   

Biden: “I did it.”

9:53 p.m. Joe Biden, who is fighting his opponents’ evidence that it’s time for a new generation of leaders, took a eventuality during a immigration discuss to execute his knowledge as an asset.

“We all pronounce about these things,” Biden pronounced of negotiating a bipartisan agreement to residence a base causes of given migrants are seeking haven in a United States. “I did it. we did it.”

– Maureen Groppe 

Madam President 

9:47 p.m. Kamala Harris, one of a 3 women on stage, got a whoop from a assembly when she finished a infrequent anxiety to a subsequent boss being womanlike if she is elected.

Asked what she would do on migrants seeking entry, Harris said: “I will safeguard that this microphone that a boss of a United States binds in her palm is used in a proceed that is about reflecting a values of a republic and not about locking children up, separating them from their parents.”

– Maureen Groppe

Trump wades in 

9:43 p.m. President Donald Trump, in his initial twitter during a second night of a presidential discuss in Miami, bloody Democrats for observant their health caring skeleton would offer coverage for immigrants in a republic illegally.

He expected their answer would volume to a “end of that race.”

“All Democrats usually lifted their hands for giving millions of bootleg aliens total healthcare,” Trump tweeted. “How about holding caring of American Citizens first!? That’s a finish of that race!”

– John Fritze

Show of hands

9:38 p.m. All a possibilities lifted their hands when asked if undocumented immigrants would be lonesome underneath their ideal health caring plan. That enclosed Joe Biden, even yet Obamacare did not concede that.

“It’s a benevolent thing to do,” Biden said.

Pete Buttigieg pronounced undocumented immigrants mostly compensate sales and skill taxes.

“This is not about a handout. This is about an word program,” he said, pivoting to say the genuine problem is a republic doesn’t have a route to citizenship for a estimated 11 million undocumented immigrants.

– Maureen Groppe 

Healthcare gets personal

9:35 p.m. Partly given Joe Biden is during a core of a stage, yet partly also given a possibilities tonight seem to be spending some-more time on a issue, a possibilities have framed health caring in intensely personal terms.

Biden, of course, told a story of his son, Beau, a former Delaware Attorney General, who died of mind cancer in 2015. Michael Bennet remarkable that he was recently diagnosed with prostate cancer.

“The quickest, fastest proceed (to urge health care) is to build on Obamacare,” Biden said, adding he’s opposite any Republican or Democrat who wants to take down Obama’s signature domestic process achievement.

“There are millions of people in America who do not have health word today,” Bennet said.

– John Fritze

Abolish private insurance?

9:30 p.m. In a repeat doubt from Wednesday night, moderators asked a 10 possibilities for a uncover of hands about who would be peaceful to discharge private insurance.

Bernie Sanders and Kamala Harris were a usually possibilities to lift their hands.

In a initial spin of a debates Wednesday, Elizabeth Warren and Bill de Blasio were a usually dual possibilities who pronounced abolishing private word creates sense.

– Michael Collins

Food fight 

9:22 p.m. The second discuss was expected to embody some-more fireworks – given there is some-more during interest for a possibilities heading in polls, like Joe Biden and Kamala Harris – and, so far, it has.

In several instances in a initial minutes, a possibilities have been forced to scream over any other. Such exchanges can mostly lead to a touching impulse for any one of a candidates.

Harris got a initial such opportunity.

“America does not wish to declare a food fight,” Harris interrupted, quieting a theatre during a argument. “They wish to know how we’re going to put food on a table.”

– John Fritze

Torch song

9:20 p.m. Eric Swalwell, who took a appropriate during Joe Biden’s age before a discuss started, pronounced he was 6 years aged when a presidential claimant came to a California Democratic gathering and pronounced it’s time to pass a flame to a new generation.

“That was Joe Biden,” Swalwell said, as a camera hold a smiling Biden.

The judge asked Biden if he would like to sing a flame song.

“I’m still holding on to that torch,” Biden said.

Then a theatre developed into a bit of a riot as Pete Buttigieg attempted to get in as “the youngest male on stage” while Bernie Sanders butted in “as partial of Joe’s generation.”

– Maureen Groppe

A tie-less Yang

9:19 p.m. Entrepreneur Andrew Yang finished an astonishing conform choice for one of his many high-profile inhabitant appearances: No tie. 

Yang, a tip symbol of his blue dress jauntily undone, is a usually masculine claimant on theatre sans necktie.

Another conform fact: Buttigieg is wearing a suit, something he frequency does on a discuss trail.

– John Fritze

Mayor Pete creates history

9:16 p.m. No matter how a rest of a night goes, Pete Buttigieg already has finished history. The mayor of South Bend, Ind., is a initial plainly LGBTQ claimant to mount on a theatre and take partial in a presidential debate.

Talking about a need for affordable college, Buttigieg also mentioned his husband, Chasten, who is a teacher. It was a initial time that a presidential claimant has referenced a same-sex associate during a debate.

– Michael Collins

Biden creates representation to core class

9:12 p.m. Former Vice President Joe Biden, asked how he would bargain with income inequality, affianced to discharge a GOP taxation cuts authorized in 2017.

He also stressed a need to “return grace to a core class” by creation certain they have affordable word and education.

– Michael Collins

‘Yes, they will compensate some-more in taxes’

9:08 p.m.  The initial doubt goes to Bernie Sanders.

It took dire by a moderator, yet Sanders pronounced on a third try that taxes on a core category would go adult to compensate for his proposals of Medicare-for all and giveaway college tuition.

“You’re utterly right. We have a new prophesy for America,” Sanders said. “We consider it is time for genuine change.”

Sanders pronounced all of his proposals would be paid for.

“Yes, they will compensate some-more in taxes,” he said, yet he combined that would equivalent for many Americans given of reduce medical costs.

– Maureen Groppe

And they’re off

9:01 p.m. Round dual has begun.

Smack in a core of a theatre during a Adrienne Arsht Center for a Performing Arts in Miami are check leaders Bernie Sanders and Joe Biden. Those dual paint a many on-going and some-more centrist wings of a party.

Flanking them are a subsequent tier of hopefuls: Pete Buttigieg, who has enjoyed a biggest arise given a commencement of a year, and Kamala Harris.

Next to Harris, her Senate colleagues Kirsten Gillibrand and Michael Bennet are looking to pierce adult in a hierarchy.

Those rounding out a final tier on a edges of a theatre are Eric Swalwell on a distant right and, on a left side, businessman Andrew Yang, John Hickenlooper and Marianne Williamson.  

Like a 10 Democrats who debated Wednesday, tonight’s hopefuls have their initial possibility to denote given they are best matched to take on President Donald Trump in Nov 2020.

The discuss is airing on NBC, MSNBC and Telemundo.

– Maureen Groppe

Spousal support

8:45 p.m. Kamala Harris’ husband, Douglas Emhoff, sent a open valentine to his mother on Twitter half an hour before she took a stage. “The whole republic is going to see what we get to see everyday,” he tweeted.

Harris will be one of 3 women debating Thursday, following a 3 women who seemed Wednesday.

Another bargain husband, Chasten Buttigieg, tweeted a print display him assisting Pete Buttigieg with his tie. “You’ve got this,” he said.

– Maureen Groppe

First appropriate of a night

8:30 p.m. Eric Swalwell did not wait for a discuss to take a appropriate during a frontrunner in polling, Joe Biden.

“I don’t consider we can commission a claimant who has been in supervision for longer than 20 years,” Swalwell told CNN.

The critique underscores what awaits Biden on theatre in Miami: A swarming margin of Democrats seeking to cut into his frontrunner status. If his challengers take that normal approach, it will symbol a vital depart from Wednesday’s debate, when usually about everybody directed transparent of aggressive Biden.

Swalwell became a member of a Dublin Town Council in 2010 and was a prosecutor and emissary district attorney before that, according to his congressional biography.  He was inaugurated to Congress in 2012.

– John Fritze

Will Biden be a target?

7:45 p.m. Joe Biden, a frontrunner in a outrageous Democratic field, could be a remarkable man in Miami on Wednesday.

The former clamp boss holds a double-digit lead, and some-more than half of a margin registers in a low-single digits or worse in inhabitant polls. So it could be tempting for rivals to concentration on Biden as a container tries to convince electorate to demeanour over a many obvious Democrat running.

– Aamer Madhani

Man arrested during initial night

7:34 p.m. A California masculine was arrested on Wednesday for allegedly intruding on possibilities as they were onstage scheming forward of a initial night of a Democratic discuss in Miami, military said. 

Austin Ogg, 30, attempted to enter a Adrienne Arsht Center during 5:30 p.m., yet was told by a declare he could not go inside given he did not have correct credentials, according to an detain news by a Miami-Dade Police Department. He was given a tamper warning.

Democratic discuss 2019: What we need to know

Who’s running?: Who is regulating for boss in 2020? An interactive guide

At 6:23 p.m., Ogg allegedly returned to a building and was authorised to enter given he told a confidence ensure he indispensable to use a bathroom. 

Ogg stayed in a lavatory for about an hour before he “made his proceed to a auditorium where domestic possibilities were on stage,” according to a report.

– Melissa Montoya, Fort Myers News-Press

Not a conform show

6:58 p.m. Some possibilities might use tone to mount out on a discuss theatre tonight, as Tulsi Gabbard did with her red coupler Wednesday. But Pete Buttigieg’s husband, Chasten Buttigieg, signaled that we shouldn’t design a confidant choice from a midwestern Mayor.

– Maureen Groppe

15.3 million watched initial debate

6:55 p.m. More than 15 million people tuned in for a initial Democratic presidential discuss Wednesday, according to total expelled by NBC.

The ratings were usually subsequent a series of people who watched a initial Democratic discuss of a 2016 cycle, yet distant subsequent a numbers for a initial Republican discuss of that year, that drew some-more than 20 million viewers.

NBC officials pronounced a initial debate, that did not underline many of a best-performing possibilities in polls, kick each primary discuss during a 2008 and 2012 cycles. Figures for tonight’s discuss will be accessible midday Friday.

– John Fritze

Who’s on stage?

6:45 p.m. Former Vice President Joe Biden, Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont, Sen. Kamala Harris of California, South Bend, Indiana, Mayor Pete Buttigieg, Sen. Michael Bennet of Colorado, author Marianne Williamson, Rep. Eric Swalwell of California, Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand of New York, businessman Andrew Yang, and former Colorado Gov. John Hickenlooper.

– Rebecca Morin

De Blasio apologizes for quoting Che Guevara

6:25 p.m. New York Major Bill de Blasio apologized Thursday for regulating a quote from scandalous Argentine insubordinate Ernesto “Che” Guevara during a convene in Miami.

Before giving adult a microphone during a Miami International Airport, de Blasio quoted out a mantra from Guevara, “Hasta la victoria, siempre,” according to a Miami Herald. Miami Democrats bloody a quote and called on a New York mayor to apologize.

The quote itself, that means “ever on to victory,” isn’t controversial. But a insubordinate best famous for a quote, Guevara, is.

Guevara, who worked closely with Cuba’s Fidel Castro, is widely unpopular with Miami’s vast Cuban population.

“I did not know a word we used in Miami currently was compared with Che Guevara we did not meant to provoke anyone who listened it that way. we positively apologize for not bargain that history,” de Blasio tweeted Thursday forward of a second Democratic discuss in Miami.

“I usually meant it as a verbatim summary to a distinguished airfield workers that we believed they would be winning in their strike.”

– John Fritze

Post to Facebook

Posted!

A couple has been posted to your Facebook feed.

• 1 of 26
• 2 of 26
• 3 of 26
• 4 of 26
• 5 of 26
• 6 of 26
• 7 of 26
• 8 of 26
• 9 of 26
• 10 of 26
• 11 of 26
• 12 of 26
• 13 of 26
• 14 of 26
• 15 of 26
• 16 of 26
• 17 of 26
• 18 of 26
• 19 of 26
• 20 of 26
• 21 of 26
• 22 of 26
• 23 of 26
• 24 of 26
• 25 of 26
• 26 of 26

Last SlideNext Slide

Sneak peek

6:15 p.m. The second spin of debaters have a advantage of saying how a initial played out. Candidates can design to be asked about their vulnerabilities, for example. Joe Biden no doubt has a prepared answer if a moderators pierce adult comments he finished this month about working with segregationist senators early in his career. Pete Buttigieg, who has struggled to win over African American voters, will expected be questioned about his doing of a deadly sharpened of a black masculine by a white military officer. 

And all a possibilities need to be prepared if a moderators ask, as they did on a initial night, for a uncover of hands for anyone who would get absolved of private health word in preference of a government-run plan. (Only Elizabeth Warren and Bill de Blasio lifted their palm Wednesday night.)

– Maureen Groppe

Analysis: Debate spotlighted differences over how distant left a Democratic Party should move

When do we vote?: When are a 2020 presidential choosing primaries

First spin results

6:15 p.m. Sure, each media outlet – including USA TODAY – has published a list of winners and losers from a initial debate. But what do a bookies think? Betting aggregators US-Bookies.com announced Cory Booker, Amy Klobuchar and Julian Castro a vast winners Wednesday, formed on how many their contingency of apropos president, or apropos a Democratic nominee, improved. 

The contingency of Castro heading a Democratic ticket, for example, condensed from 100/1 to 66/1 – a biggest burst of a night. His contingency of apropos president, however, still lay during 100/1.

The contingency makers rate Bill de Blasio a biggest loser, after his contingency of apropos boss extended from 150/1 to 200/1.

– Maureen Groppe

First night of Democratic debate: Who were a winners and losers

Debate rules 

5:30 p.m. The debates, that will began during 9 p.m. EDT, will atmosphere on NBC, MSNBC and Telemundo.

In a mangle from past presidential debates, a possibilities will not broach opening remarks. They will have 60 seconds to answer questions and 30 seconds to respond to follow-ups, according to NBC. There will be 5 segments distant by 4 blurb breaks.

“Today” co-anchor Savannah Guthrie, “NBC Nightly News” horde Lester Holt, “Meet a Press” judge Chuck Todd, MSNBC host Rachel Maddow and “Noticias Telemundo” horde José Diaz-Balart will be a moderators.

– Rebecca Morin

Article source: http://rssfeeds.usatoday.com/~/603749494/0/usatodaycomwashington-topstories~Itaposs-over-In-feisty-second-night-of-Democratic-debates-Joe-Biden-was-battered-Kamala-Harris-strong/