As Trudeau and Trump meet, farmers fear apropos a negotiate chip: Don Pittis

When he shows a design of U.S. President Donald Trump during a tillage speaking tour, rancher and rural economist Philip Shaw gets quite a reaction.  

“The room only erupts,” he says.

“The story of 2017, for Canadian agriculture, there’s one story and that’s Donald Trump,” says Shaw.

Despite a things they don’t like about stream trade rules, people in cultivation are nervous about what will occur should a North American Free Trade Agreement be reopened.

That excitability is not found only in Canada, though in a U.S. and Mexico as well, in what has turn a deeply integrated North American marketplace in rural products.

Philip Shaw, rancher and rural economist, says Donald Trump’s choosing will be a biggest thing to impact Canadian farmers in 2017. (Shaw family)

In tillage circles, Shaw is a reputable commentator on rural issues on both sides of a border. His speak on financial risk government where he showed a print of Trump was partial of a 10-stop “Agriculture Roadshow” sponsored by a taxation and accounting partnership BDO Canada.

As a farmer, Shaw hears what other farmers are saying. And people in many tools of a North American cultivation industry are fearful Trump will dissapoint a apple cart.

“Farmers are articulate about, they worry about, Donald Trump and how he competence change a NAFTA agreement,” says Shaw.

Many Canadians consider of a United States as an industrial economy, though a U.S. has historically been a outrageous rural exporter. The plantation run has a lot of poke in Congress, and a grain-producing “corn belt” voted solidly for Trump.

A ‘farm bust’

Part of that vote was a protest because all is not good in a U.S. plantation sector. High prices a few years ago due to drought and surging demand from a flourishing Chinese center category have incited to glut.

All that income invested by farmers in land and apparatus is not ensuing in hoped-for returns.

The U.S. stays a vast exporter. But, as happened in the run-up in oil prices, when agricultural prices rose, countries around a universe stretched food production, bringing 70 million new hectares into cultivation.

U.S. rancher Grant Kimberley checks corn plants in 2016, nearby Maxwell, Iowa.The biggest marketplace for U.S. corn is Mexico, and that has driven Mexican farmer farmers out of business. (Charlie Neibergall/Associated Press)

“The bang speedy farmers in other countries to ramp adult production,” pronounced a news final week in a Wall Street Journal patrician The Next American Farm Bust Is Upon Us. “Lower prolongation costs, vicinity to fast-growing markets and improving infrastructure gave some abroad farmers an edge.”

Now, North American farmers and rural industries are disturbed they could turn a negotiate chip in a renegotiated NAFTA.

Mexico buys U.S. corn

For a United States, Mexico is a Number One importer of corn, dairy products, pig and rice. It’s a tighten second and third in soybeans, beef, wheat and cotton. Any U.S. pierce to tax Mexican automobile prolongation could outcome in a countervailing separator to agricultural products.

As Prime Minister Justin Trudeau meets Trump today, Shaw is disturbed Canadian farmers could be sacrificed to protection industrial entrance to a U.S. market. 

The limit between Canada and a United States for pellet has been open for decades, he says. That means any intrusion in U.S. exports could have an impact here.

But distant some-more critical to Canadian farmers would be concessions on dairy or changes in a manners on red meat.

Canada’s dairy farmers fear they could be sacrificed in sell for Canadian entrance to industrial markets, formulating a competition to a bottom on plantation prices. (Natalia Goodwin/CBC)

“From a Canadian perspective, there competence be a trade-off to save a automobile attention by trade off entrance to a Canadian dairy market,” says Shaw. He fears attempts to help U.S. plantation exports will only import American problems here.

It won’t assistance Canadian consumers, he says, only a food industry middlemen. For farmers it’s a competition to starvation wages. 

‘America’ first

Shaw says Trump’s “America First” slogan, definition United States first, is harrowing for Canadian beef producers who have fought a prolonged conflict with a U.S. over country-of-origin rules that announced Canadian beef foreign.

Like a automobile industry, beef prolongation is so integrated opposite a border, from feed to stock to meat, that such manners are noticed by Canadian producers as pristine protectionism.

“You have Canadian farmers with Canadian cows that go over to Colorado to be fed in a winter,” says Shaw. “Sometimes they come behind to be slaughtered in Canada and afterwards a beef goes behind to a United States.”

How such perplexing cross-border trade would be influenced by a Trump border taxation stays a mystery.

While trade figure uncover Mexico exports some-more rural furnish to a U.S. than it imports, most of that upsurge comes from companies integrated into U.S. agribusiness, while farmer farmers suffer. (Carlos Jasso/Reuters)

Trump also paints a picture of Mexican workers and companies hidden U.S. jobs. But according to Judith Teichman, who has been studying Mexican domestic economy for years and writes a blog on a subject, U.S. rural exports have had a harmful outcome on a Mexican economy.

She says balance-of-trade total between a U.S. and Mexico are “fake accounting” that omit a fact that Mexican exporters paint U.S. agribusiness firms while U.S. corn exports have killed off jobs in keep agriculture.

“One of a things we have to remember is that when NAFTA was negotiated between a 3 countries Mexico was still an peremptory regime,” says Teichman, a highbrow during a University of Toronto. “They could happily omit farmer producers and listen to other absolute groups.”

She says with Mexican elections entrance subsequent year and a pro-farmer claimant heading a pack, that will no longer be a box if NAFTA is reopened now.

Follow Don on chatter @don_pittis

More analysis from Don Pittis

Article source: http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/nafta-agriculture-mexico-canada-trade-1.3974167?cmp=rss